My most recent listen yielded some concerns about levels and that's sort of mostly it.
Here's what I altered/fixed to get to 2nd final.
-
tw fix bass note at end of where am i
-
tw test 1 beat up faster for psych surfer - wound up going from 193-196
-
Turn the shaker down or look at the brightness characteristics of the new filter on solace
-
Turn the liquidator down half a decibel
-
Warming filter is too much on crossfire
-
Filter is too much on psychedelic surfer THERE WA SNO FILTER YA MUGGINS so i added 1
-
Revert to previous Mastering for King is back
-
where am i Unusual kick drum In the first bridge like it’s overloading
-
Harmonica chords in the second chorus are still not well positioned and do not pan
-
Intro between Coggins on the right to centre just ahead of the solo is still out of whack by half a bar
-
Second yearning still has a big volume jump on the YEH sound in the final chorus
-
Turn castaway down one
-
where am i harp chorus 2 fix again
-
turn up paul surany in heavens on my shoulder
-
coggers solo intro where am i
-
speed up crossfire by a small amount
-
trim entry points
-
increase bpm heavens
-
fix front of heavens has been clipped
-
turn solace down a smidge
-
figure out the nasty hi freqs in pauls guitar heavens on my shoulder, probably the new reverb
-
TW - where am i not toppy enough. check filters
Nutshell: up/down volume wise, on/off some filters, increased some songs speed by a small amount to keep the flow of the album, small continued bits of mixing.
This is what is meant by the 'top down' mix - usually, and historically for us, you complete a mix and hand it to a masterer.
As I learned from Anonymous Super Producer in LA, the way the Big Boys are doing it is...
- convert all drums to midi and replace with samples
- nest all projects whilst running through the final mastering filter.
Part 1 i wont do cos Theo. Although I have sampled in kick from time to time.
Part 2 is the top down mixing, so I think this process we have developed for it is pretty much right. I find it similar to visual editing. It's the same process of running your eye (ear) over the piece from start to finish until you forget it's your song/work and it just seems like something that has always been that way.
The fact that you can heal the issues lower down in the chain is awesome and new.
i know for old school people this is WTF and why and surely you have the discipline to do it old school and yeah we've done everything pre 2020 that way, but time moves on and tech changes, formats change and that's part of it.
What we are making now could only be made this way, and it is as it is because of it. Such has been the case with each release. From the wedding venue we converted to a studio in Bawley Point to the wooden hall at the Mangrove Mountain Community Centre, AJ's place in Indiana, Gary's place in Clarksdale, Eddy Avenue at 3am, the Dome at the Skydome Observatory near Parkes.
Tape, 1/2 inch, 2 inch, ipads, ZOOM recorded, laptops, pretty much everything that records sound, excepting an edison wax cylinder.
My Anonymous Super Producer also made comment to the effect that new and emerging software will do more and more of the mixing until he's out of a job. As robots are now also making music, i guess we'll be in the same breadline thereafter. Eventually the robots will just jam with each other while we oil them.
Meanwhile, the work continues. I had an insight that you have to like this sort of thing in order to do this sort of thing and I am coming to agree with that idea. Theo watched as i did some fixing of some...anonymous...guitarists timing and shook his head. For me though it feels like solving a puzzle, until it's what it ought to be. I think you gotta like it to do it and luckily for us, me, and our budget, I am into it and enjoying the buttons.
Next: same again. Reviewing it until i run out of interruptions to my ear. When it locks into place it's a real change. Like the difference between dough and bread. I think I got a little further yesterday and these changes are totally appropriate producer choices based on the 'album' as differentiated from the singles.
It's kind of like dropping a super bouncy ball. Each bounce gets a little smaller until it settles. I'd like to say 2-3 more passes but I can't know until it all clicks. What I can report is that I am running out of things to fix and a lot of this stuff is polishing. I am carefully walking the fine line between the effort to get work complete and the almost-impossible-to-use-rational-thought-to-describe 'sense' of when things are ready.
Will keep you guys posted.